8th Generation Honda Civic Forum banner

DIY: R18 PCV Valve replacement

125K views 70 replies 23 participants last post by  THEDUKEOFHELL  
Thanks for the post. I can't tell you how many mechanics could not find my PCV valve or would just blow me off and say "that's not really a serviceable part" My 2008 Civic LX has had some rough idle issues and also poor gas mileage lately. I am going down a list of potential suspects and doing most of it myself and the valve came up. Thanks to your post, I easily replaced it yesterday!
So did new PCV help your rough idle & poor MPG?? :waiting:
 
Any tips on removing the rubber hose from the PCV valve? Should I pry it up from the bottom using a flat blade screwdriver as I pull up on it? Or should I just grab the hose & pull up, although it seems like it is on there awfully tight? Or should I put a rag on the hose, grab with pliers, then pull?
 
What is the range on your torque range? Unless it's 0-100 ft-lbs, it probably wasn't accurate enough at 33 ft-lbs to actually apply only 33 ft-lbs. IMO, 33 ft-lbs means hand-tight with simple hand tools.
33 ft-lbs is a bit more than hand tight. As a comparison, the torque spec for the spark plugs is 18 ft-lbs, so PCV torque is nearly double that of spark plugs.

Another way to look at it -- if you're applying force on a typical ratchet that you're grabbing 6-inches from the axis of revolution, 33 ft-lbs is 66 pounds of force at 6 inches!
 
I have the same issue to remove the hose, it is really tight. I am afraid to pull it hard and will break the hose. Would that BP blaster loose the hose as well ?
I found the hose is softer when the engine is still warm , guess it would make to remove the hose easier.

any advice ?

thanks
I'm in the same boat. I've postponed replacing my PCV valve for a few months now, because I had no luck removing the dang hose. :bleh:
 
1. Is that all you replaced, the only maintenance you performed to gain that kind of mileage?

2. Do you have actual mgp calcs?

3. What were your other symptoms? How much oil were you consuming and how has it improved?

What you're posting is an INCREDIBLE change for only a PCV valve replacement...
^^^^^ I had the same questions when I read the post. Hard to believe.
 
Did this on my car.. It's at 112,000 miles and has been burning a bit of oil. Put 250 KM on it and the gas gauge has dropped 4 bars, as opposed to the nearly full tank it would burn doing similar driving before. So a 23 dollar part is going to save me hundreds in gas. Also my car doesn't hesitate anymore OR fluctuate when it idles.


Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
1. Is that all you replaced, the only maintenance you performed to gain that kind of mileage?

2. Do you have actual mpg calcs?

3. What were your other symptoms? How much oil were you consuming and how has it improved?

What you're posting is an INCREDIBLE change for only a PCV valve replacement...

Any comments X_Civic??
 
I have an ‘08 Civic EX with 67,000 miles and the original PCV valve. Decided to replace it last week since the part is inexpensive. VERY glad I did. The idle is much much smoother, like butter. Acceleration is also better due to less hesitation. My OCD brain can say that with confidence!!
I’ve driven both on the highway and in stop & go traffic with the new PCV valve. I highly recommend replacement to anyone, especially if your current valve has 60k miles or more.
P.S—I’ve not yet gone through a full tank, so I cannot presently speak to the mpg.