Well fingerprints aren't a big deal since you can wipe them off.
I think more important is what happened when you complained to them about the issue--did you talk to them, and are they doing anything to resolve it? I don't care to stand up for them, but without talking about their customer service in your post it seems too preliminary to put out a buyer's beware.
And man that color really doesn't match. Is that Ralleye Red?